Is peace between India & Pakistan possible? Personally, I don’t have an answer. I think nobody has the answer, not even the peace initiators from India (mostly Indians start such peace initiatives and unfortunately it takes attacks like 26/11 in Mumbai for Pakistan to block them).
I don’t think there is anything wrong with such peace initiatives. Indians are intrinsically peaceful people and tolerantly secular if compared to Pakistanis. This is not a subjective view but an objective analysis knowing Pakistanis in reel and real life.
If you go through any Pakistani forum, you will know what Pakistan’s internet society thinks about Indians (particularly Hindus), Hinduism (and other non-Islamic Indian religions like Jainism, Sikhism, Buddhism), Indians’ skin color, preference for vegetarianism etc. All of these topics are discussed in an extreme undignified manner with the intent of humiliating and degrading Indians. The Pakistani views reflect a lot of ignorance, hatred, colorism, religious-bias but at the same time a huge inferiority complex.
Almost all forums have comparative threads about which country is the best in any particular thing and 99% of the times Pakistan is declared as the best and India as a loser. I don’t know if such discussions can be termed as a battle for lack of self-confidence among Pakistanis or an identity crisis. I don’t know if they are spoon-fed hatred toward India but it is very hard for me to conclude much from Internet. So, I resort to the Pakistanis I know in my real life and regretfully they aren’t much different from their compatriots on the Internet. I have hardly found anything constructive and positive in most of what Pakistanis write pertaining India.
On the other hand, when you visit Indian forums, you will hardly find the mention of Pakistan, Pakistanis or Islam except the forums which contain terrorism related subjects. Indians don’t compare India with Pakistan but with bigger economies like China, USA and EU. It’s called thinking out of the box and not being stuck in the past, which is good.

Unfortunately, Aman ki Asha does not have much importance in such hate driven minds of people who proudly talk about something called GHAZWA-E-HIND. As for India, Pakistan as a tiny country should have little to no significance in world politics. India gives too much of importance to this country in the region. It is unfortunate that India has this terror hub in its backyard but India should focus more on how to deal with Pakistan’s anti-India strategists rather than dealing with Pakistan’s ‘civil society’ (if there is any) which has no power whatsoever to change the hostility which exists between these two countries. At most, people to people contact can make it easier for Pakistanis to reap the benefits of India’s economy in doing business, Indians don’t benefit from Pakistanis in any way.
Lastly, I would like to refer to a comment by a fellow Indian regarding this ‘Aman ki Asha’ initiative by Times of India on YouTube:
‘Our ethos as Indians and our culture are as different as chalk and cheese. Their [Pakistanis’] biggest political demand from their government is democracy something that we take for granted. For them religion is the centerpiece of all debates while for us it is economy/education. They take utmost pride on building atom bomb. We hardly talk about atom bomb. For us our corporates, NRIs, Chandrayaan, Bollywood, outsourcing industry are the matter of biggest pride. We are different.’ — vinaydey2006